What Makes a Great Pesto, According to an Expert (2024)

Pesto, that beguiling, fragrant, emerald green sauce of pounded basil leaves, garlic, pine nuts, olive oil, and Parmigiano cheese, is one of Italy's most famous contributions to the culinary world. And it is the defining flavor of Liguria, the rugged coastal sweep of northwestern Italy where it originated. Tossed with freshly cooked pasta, drizzled on poached or baked fish, dolloped on vegetable minestrone, pesto has the power to brighten and enliven any dish it meets. If you've only ever tried jarred pesto, do yourself a favor and make a homemade batch. It's easy to do if you follow a few key steps. Once you've tried it, you'll wonder how you ever lived without it.

What Makes a Great Pesto, According to an Expert (1)

What Is Pesto?

The word "pesto" comes from the Italian verb "pestare," which means "to pound." Simply put, pesto is a raw sauce or mixture made by pounding various ingredients together in a mortar and pestle. The vibrant green basil sauce that the word "pesto" conjures for most of us is pesto alla Genovese. It gets its name from the city of Genoa, the hilly capital of Liguria where basil is cultivated in profusion, and where the sauce is believed to have originated sometime in the 17th century. The other ingredients in traditional pesto are garlic, pine nuts, salt, olive oil and Parmigiano cheese, or a mix of Parmigiano and pecorino cheeses.

There are many iterations of pesto, both traditional and nontraditional. Pesto alla Trapanese, named for the city of Trapani, in Sicily, swaps in almonds for pine nuts and adds a handful of cherry tomatoes. There's also arugula pesto, cilantro pesto, parsley pesto, lovage pesto, sun-dried tomato pesto, spinach pesto, tarragon pesto, roasted tomato pesto and more.

To make traditional pesto, look for young basil, with leaves no bigger than the pad of your thumb. Mature basil has a strong flavor and is too "woody" to be pounded to a creamy consistency. To make it, pound the ingredients, first separately and then together, using a marble mortar and wooden pestle, until everything is reduced to a creamy sauce.

Nowadays, a food processor or bullet blender usually takes the place of the mortar and pestle and makes quick work of the task, grinding and pureeing everything together.

What Is Pesto Made Of?

Pesto contains just a few ingredients: fresh basil leaves, garlic, pine nuts, salt, olive oil and Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese.

True pesto Genovese is made with Genovese basil from the hills of Genoa, harvested while the leaves are still small and very tender; mild garlic (ideally from nearby Vessalico); pine nuts (all the better if they come from the area around Pisa); coarse sea salt; buttery, mild olive oil from Liguria; and Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese, or a mix of Parmigiano and Pecorino Sardo, an aged sheep's-milk cheese from Sardinia.

Those of us who love pesto but live nowhere near Liguria can be less picky about the provenance of the ingredients we use.

What Does Pesto Taste Like?

If the Garden of Eden had a flavor, it would be pesto: sweet, floral, salty, rich, herbaceous with a slight tinge of bitter. Properly made pesto tastes fresh and zingy and balanced, not muddy. Each flavor component is identifiable—the fragrant basil, the pungent garlic, the buttery olive oil and sweet pine nuts, the tangy cheeses—and yet none dominates. Basil is the star, for sure, but its perfume works in balance with the other ingredients.

What's So Special About Pesto?

There's a magical quality to pesto. Tossed with hot pasta, its flavor becomes more vibrant as it warms from the residual heat. Dolloped into a bowl of minestrone, it brightens the taste of the vegetables. It can jazz up simple baked fish, and it's heaven on a tomato-and-mozzarella sandwich. It's a versatile sauce that pairs well with many flavors and dishes.

Pesto is also ideal for creative culinary riffing. While basil is the traditional herb for pesto, nothing says you can't improvise. Why not add a handful of mint from that giant mound in your garden? Or use the bunch of parsley that's been sitting in your crisper drawer? No pine nuts? Try buttery, slightly bitter walnuts instead. I like to make "white" pesto with walnuts, a small amount of fragrant herbs—basil and marjoram—and a few dollops of fresh ricotta cheese.

How Do You Eat Pesto?

The most common way to enjoy pesto is with pasta. In Liguria, traditional pasta shapes for pesto include trofie, a small corkscrew shape; trenette, similar to linguine; gnocchi; and corzetti, an embossed coin shape. Pesto for pasta is not meant to be cooked, but rather tossed raw with just-cooked pasta, along with a splash of cooking water.

Of course, there are countless other ways to put your pesto to use. Spread a little on top of grilled eggplant, mushrooms or peppers. Use it to season chicken salad or potato salad, or as a filling for stuffed chicken breasts. Thin it with a little oil and drizzle over a fresh caprese salad. It's also a delicious flavor bomb for homemade pizza, focaccia and bread.

Is Pesto Healthy?

According to Emily Lachtrupp, M.S., RD, "Pesto contains leafy greens from the basil and healthy fats from olive oil and pine nuts, making it a nutritious choice. Plus, it's packed with flavor, so a small serving goes a long way." Store-bought pestos tend to be high in sodium, so be sure to check the nutrition label when browsing your options. You can control the sodium by making your own.

Though nutrition will vary from brand to brand, here's the nutritional breakdown for 1 tablespoon of typical store-bought pesto, according to the USDA:

  • 93 calories
  • 0g fiber
  • 0g sugar
  • 1g protein
  • 9g total fat
  • 2g saturated fat
  • 3mg cholesterol
  • 158 mg sodium
  • 32mg potassium

Is Pesto Healthy? Here's What a Dietitian Says

How Long Does Pesto Last in the Refrigerator?

Although pesto can be stored in the refrigerator, its vibrant green color turns dark and murky quickly when exposed to air. To prevent discoloration, scoop the pesto into a small container and cover it with a thin layer of extra-virgin olive oil. Store in the fridge for up to three days.

Can You Freeze Pesto?

For longer storage, you can freeze pesto; it will last in the freezer for up to six months. Although you can store it in a single container, it's more convenient to portion it out between smaller airtight containers or sealable bags, which allows you to retrieve only as much as you need. You can also freeze pesto in an ice cube tray. Once frozen, pop out the individual portions and transfer them to a sealable freezer bag or airtight container and return to the freezer. This gives you conveniently small portions perfect for flavoring soups, dressings, sauces and more.

What Makes a Great Pesto, According to an Expert (2024)

FAQs

What makes pesto so good? ›

And it's those herbs—specifically basil—that makes pesto a bright mouthful of summer. Recipes often vary, but basic preparations always center on the previously mentioned basil, garlic, pine nuts and olive oil, with Italian cheeses like parmigiano reggiano and pecorino romano.

How do you pick a good pesto? ›

The best store bought pesto is herby, garlicky, and nutty. It should be oily, but not too oily. The best jarred pesto doesn't need to have cheese—but if it does have cheese, there should be a lot of cheese. Most importantly, the best jarred pesto shouldn't have a weird, funky twang.

What should good pesto taste like? ›

What does pesto taste like? Traditional pesto is a thick, green sauce that tastes bright and herby from the basil, and salty and rich from the cheeses and pine nuts. It should be garlicky, with pleasant grassiness from good quality olive oil.

What qualifies a pesto? ›

Pesto (Italian: [ˈpesto]) is a paste that traditionally consists of crushed garlic, European pine nuts, coarse salt, basil leaves, and hard cheese such as Parmesan or pecorino sardo (cheese made from sheep's milk), all blended with olive oil. It originated in Genoa, the capital city of Liguria, Italy.

Why does my homemade pesto taste bad? ›

The most common reason for pesto tasting bitter is that the olive oil is past its best and has started to turn rancid. If the pesto has been made in a food processor or blender, there's also the possibility that it has turned bitter from the crude, sheering action of the blades.

What things compliment pesto? ›

Add a Mediterranean spin to your morning mushrooms on toast with fresh green pesto, melted mozzarella and sundried tomatoes - perfect for a weekend brunch. A dollop of pesto would also be the perfect partner for smoked salmon and scrambled eggs, or could be mixed into a tasty green omelette.

What cuts bitterness in pesto? ›

Acid in the form of vinegar or citrus juices can make a pesto taste less bitter and could even enhance the flavour of the sauce at the same time. In low concentrations, salt can be used to suppress bitterness, which is why people have been adding tiny amounts to coffee for decades. Always go easy to start with.

How can you tell if pesto is good? ›

If your pesto has turned brown instead of green, that's another clear sign that it's rancid. And there's always the smell test: it will have a strong sour smell once it turns. But as always, it's better to err on the side of caution and throw the pesto out if you've got any doubts.

Should pesto be served warm or cold? ›

PESTO SHOULD NEVER BE “COOKED”. If you cook Pesto Sauce, you change the make up of the fresh basil and cause it to turn darker in color. It is best to warm it up and use it at room temperature. If it needs to be thinned out, you can do so by adding a little water, chicken stock, cream or white wine.

What nuts taste best in pesto? ›

Pistachios, almonds, and walnuts or even seeds like sunflower, sesame, and pumpkin can replace the traditional pine nuts in pesto. Pretty much any edible nut tastes delicious—just make sure to toast and cool the nut before grinding them into the sauce.

Why does my pesto pasta taste bland? ›

You do not need to cook pesto, as its flavours are best enjoyed raw. Instead, allow the residual heat from your freshly cooked pasta to gently warm it as you stir it in. Why is my pesto bland? It's likely because you need to add more basil or salt.

What tastes better red or green pesto? ›

While green pesto tends to taste very earthy, red pesto is incredibly bright with rich notes of umami. What gives red pesto its bright hue is a mix of sun-dried tomatoes and roasted red peppers. It's delicious on its own, or paired with just about any protein: grilled chicken, shrimp, steak, or meatballs.

What do Italians eat pesto with? ›

Italian Tradition

Pesto is the perfect sauce to enjoy with a dish of trofie (the traditional Ligurian short pasta), lasagna, potato gnocchi or as a topping for a bowl of minestrone. It can be mixed into tomato sauce to enhance the flavor of pasta dishes or used with fish fillets to make them more appetizing.

What is so special about pesto? ›

Pesto is flavorful and bright and can liven up vegetables, pizza, potatoes and pasta. It's also high in healthy fats, which help keep you satisfied. Fat may be higher in calories, but it also takes longer to digest (read: satisfying) and allows your body to absorb fat-soluble vitamins, A, D, E and K.

What is a creamy pesto? ›

Creamy Pesto Pasta is a delicious recipe in which pasta is tossed in basil pesto sauce which consists of crushed garlic, pine nuts, fresh basil leaves and Parmesan cheese, all blended with olive oil.

Is pesto unhealthy or healthy? ›

Because its ingredients include olive oil, nuts, and cheese, pesto can be high in calories and fat. However, the fat is primarily unsaturated and may have heart health benefits. Pesto is also full of antioxidants that can help protect your cells from damage.

Is pesto healthier than tomato? ›

As you would expect, pesto's wider variety of ingredients means it does slightly better in the vitamin and mineral stakes. Pesto outsmarts tomato sauce in many of these, but the pasta sauce still provides a sizeable chunk of your recommended daily targets.

Why is pesto so expensive? ›

Its scarcity, plus the fact that the plants are picked roots, soil, and all to ensure that only juvenile leaves make it into pesto, makes it extraordinarily expensive and something that only premium, artisan pesto makers can justify using.

Is pesto good for your stomach? ›

Studies on Pesto and Digestive Health

However, studies on the individual ingredients of pesto, such as basil and garlic, suggest potential benefits for digestive health. For example, basil has been found to possess anti-inflammatory and antibacterial properties that may help alleviate symptoms associated with IBS.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Clemencia Bogisich Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5805

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Clemencia Bogisich Ret

Birthday: 2001-07-17

Address: Suite 794 53887 Geri Spring, West Cristentown, KY 54855

Phone: +5934435460663

Job: Central Hospitality Director

Hobby: Yoga, Electronics, Rafting, Lockpicking, Inline skating, Puzzles, scrapbook

Introduction: My name is Clemencia Bogisich Ret, I am a super, outstanding, graceful, friendly, vast, comfortable, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.